Compare
NoSlop vs ForgeGUI
ForgeGUI is mainly a website that makes game assets from prompts: GUI kits, icons, thumbnails, 3D models and more, for Roblox and other engines. Its ForgeMCP connector brings ForgeGUI into Claude Code or Codex, while Roblox Studio connects through Roblox’s own MCP server. NoSlop is a desktop app around your agents with its own Studio plugin, so the two overlap only in part.
Written by NoSlop, so we’re not neutral. We checked every fact about the other products on their own public pages on , and list them under Sources. These products change often, so check their sites before you decide. Found something wrong or out of date? Write to hello@noslop.gg and we’ll fix it.
At a glance
| Feature | NoSlop | ForgeGUI |
|---|---|---|
| The full app without a subscription | Yes | No |
| Runs the AI agent you already have | Yes | Yes |
| Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI and more | Yes | Partly |
| Several agents on one game at once | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| A shared task board so agents don’t clash | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Works on the Luau game you already have | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| A checkpoint before and after every task | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Your code as plain files you own | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Agents playtest and read the errors | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Agents walk the player in a playtest | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Agents take screenshots of Studio | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Finds backdoors hidden in free models | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Share a game with your team | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Visual effects (VFX) tools | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Agents set up game passes and products | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Game logs and stats in your Discord | Yes | Not described on its pages |
| Windows and Mac | Yes | Yes |
YesPartlyNoNot described on its pages
What NoSlop has that ForgeGUI doesn’t
- NoSlop Pro is €19 a month or €135 once. ForgeGUI’s paid plans start at $22 a month.
- NoSlop has its own Studio plugin and MCP server: agents start playtests, read errors, walk the player and take Studio screenshots. ForgeGUI leaves Studio to Roblox’s own MCP server.
- NoSlop works with Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, Cursor CLI, Grok Build or any MCP agent, several at once with a shared task board.
- Your scripts, UI and stored assets live as files with a Git checkpoint before and after every task. ForgeGUI’s docs describe versions of generated assets, not of game code.
Where ForgeGUI is ahead
- There is a free plan, with 10,000 credits a month for images.
- It generates thumbnails, icons, whole GUI kits from a style reference, and 3D models, ready for Roblox Studio as .rbxm or PNG.
- The asset tools work in the browser, with nothing to install.
In detail
| What | NoSlop | ForgeGUI |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A desktop app: your AI agents work in terminal panes, connected to Roblox Studio through NoSlop’s own MCP server and Studio plugin. | A web app that generates game assets from prompts: thumbnails, icons, GUI sets, 3D models and more, exported as PNG, ZIP, GLB or .rbxm. ForgeMCP connects it to Claude Code or Codex. |
| Price | NoSlop Pro: €135 once, €99 a year or €19 a month, with updates to Pro included. Max, with the big new tools (in beta), is €39 a month. More storage for games you share is an optional monthly add-on. | Free $0 (10,000 credits a month, image generations only). Creator $22 a month, Pro $50 a month, Studio $200 a month, or $18, $41.50 and $160 a month billed yearly, with 150K, 350K and 1.25M credits. |
| The AI | Your own: Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, Cursor CLI, Grok Build or any MCP agent, signed in with your account. You pay your AI provider directly; NoSlop doesn’t resell AI. | “Every top AI Model, configured for game creators, in one interface”, paid in ForgeGUI credits; its public pages don’t name the models. Its ForgeMCP setup says its coding tool “now runs on Claude Code or Codex, connected to Studio through Roblox MCP.” |
| Free plan or trial | No free plan and no trial. | Yes: a free plan with 10,000 credits a month, image generations only. |
| Computers | Windows 10/11 (64-bit) and macOS 13.5 or later on Apple silicon. | Works in the browser. For Studio, it uses your Claude Code or Codex and Roblox’s own Studio MCP server. |
| Several agents at once | Yes: as many panes as you like, with a shared task board, locks and notes, and agents take turns at Studio’s playtest. | Not described on its pages. |
| Games you already have | Yes: import a place you already have; its scripts, UI and stored assets become files your agents edit (Luau or roblox-ts). | Not described on its pages. |
| Playtesting and errors | Agents start playtests, read the output and errors with stack traces, walk the player character and take screenshots of Studio. | Not described on its pages. |
| Undo and history | A Git checkpoint of your scripts, UI and stored assets before and after every task; restoring never deletes history. The 3D world stays in Studio and is undone with Studio’s own Undo. Your project is a normal folder you can push to your own GitHub. | Its docs say every asset is “saved to your project, versioned automatically”. History for a game’s code is not described. |
| 3D models and assets | An asset library with free CC0 sounds and pictures; agents can model in Blender on your computer. | Its main job: thumbnails, icons and full GUI kits matched to a style reference, and 3D models, exported to Studio as .rbxm or as PNGs. Its app’s tool list also has rigs, Roblox animations, sound effects, music and voice-over. |
Sources, checked
- ForgeGUI home page
- ForgeGUI plans
- ForgeGUI docs
- ForgeGUI docs: exporting to Roblox Studio
- NoSlop pricing and FAQ
- NoSlop changelog
ForgeGUI and the other names here belong to their owners. NoSlop isn’t affiliated with them. Prices are as their pages showed them, in their currency.
Other comparisons
- NoSlop vs VibeStarterA desktop app that runs your own AI agents on Roblox games written in TypeScript.
- NoSlop vs RoAutomationA desktop app with an AI manager and 14 specialist agents that run on your own Claude plan. Monthly or yearly plans.
- NoSlop vs RopilotA desktop app and Studio plugin with monthly plans, for your own AI plan or Ropilot’s AI.
- NoSlop vs SuperbulletAIA Roblox AI builder with the AI included and paid in tokens. It now takes your own Claude Code or Codex plan too.
- NoSlop vs RebirthDescribe a game on the web, and Rebirth builds it in Roblox Studio on your computer. Paid per prompt.
- NoSlop vs LemonadeA Roblox game studio in the browser, with a team of AI robots. You sign in with your Roblox account.
- NoSlop vs RatebloxAn AI agent that plans your Roblox game, then builds it one tested step at a time in your open Studio place. Monthly plans with credits.